Stable -> beta regression, or I missed something?

1

I have problem with my code, it behaves in different ways, if compiled with different versions of rustc.

Here simplified code (the real one compiled and run on android, and f and main in different crates):

use std::collections::HashSet;

#[derive(PartialEq, Debug, Hash, Eq, Clone)]
enum SentenceType {
    None,
    AAM,
    //...many
    RMC,
    GGA,
    //..many
}

fn f(s: HashSet<SentenceType>) {
    println!("s: {:?}", s);
}

fn main() {
    f([SentenceType::RMC, SentenceType::GGA]
          .iter()
          .cloned()
          .collect());
}

if I compiled with stable (rustc 1.18.0 (03fc9d622 2017-06-06)), all works fine, and it prints s: {GGA, RMC}, but if code compiled with beta or nightly (.19.0-beta.2 (a175ee509 2017-06-15)/1.20.0-nightly (622e7e648 2017-06-21)) it prints:

s: {XTE, HTD, HMR, LRI, BWW, XTR, ZDA, RMC, LRF, TTM, GXA, DBT, APB, ACA, ZTG, ALM, RMA, RTE, LR1, HDG, HDT, GLC, TRF, MLA, VHW, VLW, SFI, APA, DSC, RPM, STN, HSC, DSR, HDM, VDR, TLL, LR3, BWC, AAM, ASD, DSE, RSA, GSV, DBK, DPT, GBS, BWR, GNS, ROO, None, ACK, RMB, VSD, ZFO, AIR, OSD, GGA, MSS, ACS, LR2, TXT, HMS, ALR, DBS, SSD, MWD, ABK, FSI, DSI, GSA, OLN, LCD, DTM, GTD, GMP, BEC, MTW, DCN, ZDL, VBW, GLL, VPW, GRS, VWR, MWV, TLB, CUR, VTG, BOD, WNC}

I can fix problem for beta/nightly with such code:

        let mut s = HashSet::new();
        s.insert(SentenceType::RMC);
        s.insert(SentenceType::GGA);

Because of problem can be reprodiciable only on Android/arm and in partly closed source program, before make attempt to dig it farther, I want to make sure:

  1. May be something wrong in code in question?
  2. Any known rustc bugs that may cause this?
  3. Any hints to debug this?
3

Rust 1.19 has updated to LLVM 4, so there could well be some regression in ARM codegen. FWIW, it works fine on all stable/beta/nightly on the playground: https://is.gd/zgo7my

1 Like
4

Rust 1.19 has updated to LLVM 4, so there could well be some regression in ARM codegen. FWIW, it works fine on all stable/beta/nightly on the playground: Rust Playground

It is not reproducible on x86 32/64 bits machines, only on android/arm

but I am able to reduce problem to two crates case, so I post bug here: wrong code regression: HashSet initialization · Issue #42918 · rust-lang/rust · GitHub

5

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.