Why has `SipHash` become deprecated?

The core::hash::SipHash can be accessed without std or alloc, but the recommended std::collections::hash_map::DefaultHasher can't.

There's no need for std to maintain SipHash in particular. Std needs some hash for hash map, but that hash should remain unspecified and be allowed to change. So, committing std to provide specifically SipHash just for the hashmap was a mistake, which was rectified by deprecating the functionality. It is likely that, at some point, std does switch to a different hash function, and SipHasher implementation in the stdlib is replaced with unoptimized simple implementation, to reduce the size of std.

Maybe std needs to expose a SipHash not for the purpose of seeding hash map, but for the purpose of providing basic cryptography primitives. That is, something like std::crypto::SipHash. But there's no std::crypto module today, and adding it would require much more thorough motivation that stably exposing something we already have by accident.

15 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.